Finding the right dentists in Indianapolis takes more than a quick Google search. With the American Dental Association reporting that only about 66% of U.S. adults visited a dentist in the past year, choosing a practice you trust makes all the difference in maintaining consistent care.
Indianapolis offers hundreds of dental practices, but quality varies. The practices on this list stand out for their patient reviews, credentials, range of services, and commitment to modern dental care. Whether you live near Broad Ripple, downtown, or the Southside, these five practices represent some of the best dental care the Circle City has to offer.
1. SmileCentric East
Address: 115 N Shortridge Rd #200, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Phone: (317) 747-3170
Phone: (317) 747-3170
SmileCentric East earns the top spot for its combination of comprehensive services, patient-centered care, and modern technology. Led by Dr. Louis Abukhalaf, DDS and Dr. James M Pierle, DDS, this privately owned practice delivers everything from routine cleanings to complex implant procedures.
What sets SmileCentric East apart is their approach to anxious patients. The practice offers sedation dentistry options and has built a reputation for gentle, unhurried care. They accept most PPO insurance plans and offer new patient specials for those without coverage, including a $59 comprehensive exam with X-rays.
The practice serves patients throughout Indianapolis, Geist Reservoir, Fort Harrison, South Fishers, Oaklandon, and surrounding Marion County communities. Same-day emergency appointments are available for patients experiencing tooth pain or dental trauma.
Services include family and preventive dentistry, cosmetic procedures like veneers and teeth whitening, dental implants including All-on-4 options, and Invisalign clear aligners.
2. Martin Dentistry
Address: 1724 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Phone: (317) 576-3602
Phone: (317) 576-3602
Martin Dentistry has been serving the Broad Ripple community since the practice was founded. Dr. Matthew Martin, Dr. Stephanie Martin, and Dr. Lynn Marshall lead a team that emphasizes building long-term relationships with patients.
The practice is 100% independently owned. As they put it, they are owners and operators who are part of the community rather than a corporate chain. This translates to consistent care from dentists who know your history and preferences.
Their Indianapolis location features themed treatment rooms, including a Star Wars room, along with DVD players and noise-canceling headphones to help patients relax during procedures. The practice offers sedation dentistry for nervous patients and has invested in digital technology including iTero scanners for one-visit crowns.
Martin Dentistry also maintains a location in Fishers, making them convenient for patients throughout the northern Indianapolis metro area.
3. Newman Family Dentistry
Address: 3945 Eagle Creek Pkwy, Ste A, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Phone: (317) 293-3000
Phone: (317) 293-3000
Newman Family Dentistry brings a literal family approach to dental care. The practice is led by three brothers: Dr. Don M. Newman, Dr. Marc F. Newman, and Dr. Mikel S. Newman. Their 4.9-star Google rating reflects years of consistent patient care.
The practice has earned recognition as a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite multiple years running. Patient reviews consistently mention the welcoming atmosphere and the staff’s ability to make nervous patients feel comfortable.
Newman Family Dentistry offers early morning and evening appointments to accommodate busy schedules. They provide general, restorative, and cosmetic dentistry, including dental implants, full mouth restoration, and porcelain veneers. Dr. Mikel Newman has specialized training in frenectomies for infants, making the practice a resource for new parents dealing with nursing difficulties.
With locations in both Indianapolis and Carmel, Newman Family Dentistry serves patients across the northwest side of the metro area.
4. Mass Ave Family Dentistry
Address: 310 N Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: (317) 218-9901
Phone: (317) 218-9901
Mass Ave Family Dentistry offers a unique approach to dental care in downtown Indianapolis. Dr. Katherine So brings a holistic perspective to dentistry, combining traditional treatments with attention to whole-body health. She completed her undergraduate degree at UC Berkeley before graduating from Indiana University School of Dentistry in 2012.
The downtown location includes complimentary parking for patients, addressing one of the main concerns about visiting a practice in the city center. Dr. So is a member of the International Academy of Oral Medicine and Toxicology, reflecting her interest in the broader health implications of dental care.
Patient reviews frequently mention the practice’s ability to reduce anxiety. Multiple reviewers have described falling asleep during procedures due to the gentle approach. The practice has been named a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in multiple Indianapolis neighborhoods, including Old Northside, Fletcher Place, and St Clair Place.
Services include dental implants, periodontics, oral surgery, smile makeovers, and teeth whitening.
5. Hadley Family Dentistry
Address: 5406 S Emerson Ave, Ste A, Indianapolis, IN 46237
Phone: (317) 780-7777
Phone: (317) 780-7777
Hadley Family Dentistry serves the Southside of Indianapolis with a veteran-owned practice committed to quality care. Dr. Joseph Hadley brings a unique background, having started his healthcare career as a nurse before graduating from Indiana University School of Dentistry in 2002.
The practice has grown to include multiple dentists: Dr. Chad Sloan, Dr. Lisbeth Randall, Dr. Kaleb Davis, Dr. Leah O’Gara, and Dr. Brandon Tiek. This team approach means patients rarely face long waits for appointments. Dr. Randall is a decorated U.S. Navy Veteran with expertise in dental sleep medicine and complete mouth reconstruction.
Hadley Family Dentistry maintains a 5-star average from 144 patient reviews. They have been a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite every year from 2017 through 2024. The practice prioritizes transparency in treatment recommendations and takes time to explain procedures and costs upfront.
Services include preventive care, cosmetic dentistry, dental implants, and orthodontics.
FAQs About Finding a Dentist in Indianapolis
How often should I visit the dentist?
The American Dental Association recommends visiting your dentist regularly based on your individual oral health needs. For most people, this means at least once or twice per year for checkups and cleanings. Your dentist will suggest a schedule based on your specific situation.
What should I expect at a new patient appointment?
Expect your first visit to last about an hour. The dentist will review your medical history, take X-rays, perform a comprehensive exam, and discuss any concerns you have. Many Indianapolis practices offer new patient specials that reduce the cost of this initial visit.
Do Indianapolis dentists accept insurance?
Most Indianapolis dental practices accept major PPO dental insurance plans. Many also offer financing options or in-house membership plans for patients without insurance. Call ahead to verify your specific plan is accepted.
How do I find an emergency dentist in Indianapolis?
Several practices on this list offer same-day emergency appointments. If you experience severe tooth pain, a knocked-out tooth, or other dental trauma, call your dentist first. Many maintain emergency lines or can fit you in quickly during business hours.
What is the average cost of a dental cleaning in Indianapolis?
Dental cleanings in Indianapolis typically range from $75 to $200 without insurance, according to 2023 data from the American Dental Association. Costs vary based on whether you need a routine cleaning or a deeper periodontal cleaning.
Selection Criteria
This list was compiled based on several factors: verified patient reviews across multiple platforms including Google, Yelp, and Nextdoor, dentist credentials and continuing education, range of services offered, years serving the Indianapolis community, availability of modern technology and amenities, insurance acceptance and payment options, and recognition from industry organizations and community awards. Priority was given to privately owned practices with established reputations and consistent positive feedback from patients.
Why Choose Smile Centric East?
At Smile Centric East in Indianapolis, we make your comfort and smile our top priority. From preventive care and cosmetic enhancements to restorative treatments, and implants, our experienced team provides modern, personalized dentistry for the whole family.
Read Our Reviews | Meet Your Dental Team | Schedule Your Appointment